Users' representation of the machine in human-computer speech interaction - Inria - Institut national de recherche en sciences et technologies du numérique Access content directly
Reports (Research Report) Year : 1989

Users' representation of the machine in human-computer speech interaction

René Amalberti
  • Function : Author
Noëlle Carbonell
  • Function : Author
  • PersonId : 831018
P. Falzon
  • Function : Author


We report an experiment designed in order to study whether models of human-human voice dialogues could be applied successfully to human-computer communication using spoken natural language. Two groups of 6 subjects were asked to collect information about air travel, through dialoguing with a remote interlocutor. Subjects of the machine group were led to believe they were talking to a computer, subjects of the operator group were told they were interacting with a human operator. Both groups actually talked to the same human experimenter. The study focuses on subjects' representations of interlocutor's skills and knowledge, and differs from previous analogous experiments in several respects: - the task is more complex, giving rise to structured exchanges in natural language instead of question/answers pairs in a restricted language; - specific attention has been paid to the experimental protocol, in order to avoid the possible bias of other studies (in particular, conditions are strictly identical for both groups); - evolution over time has been considered (3 sessions, with a one-week interval). Some results confirm those of the literature, namely that subjects of the machine group tend to control and simplify their linguistic expression more than those in the operator group. However, most observations are either original or in contradiction with previous results: - subjects of the machine group are more talkative; no significant difference can be detected between the two groups with respect to most aspects of linguistic practice; - concerning evolution over time: both groups tend to get more concise; with respect to scenario processing (i.e. problem solving), the strategies of the operator group evolve significantly, whilst those of the machine group remain stable. These differences in the behaviors of the two groups are ascribed to different representations of the interlocutor's abilities.


Other [cs.OH]
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
RR-1125.pdf (1.84 Mo) Télécharger le fichier

Dates and versions

inria-00075434 , version 1 (24-05-2006)


  • HAL Id : inria-00075434 , version 1


René Amalberti, Noëlle Carbonell, P. Falzon. Users' representation of the machine in human-computer speech interaction. [Research Report] RR-1125, INRIA. 1989. ⟨inria-00075434⟩
66 View
35 Download


Gmail Facebook Twitter LinkedIn More