Self-trust is overlooked in trust research. However, self-trust is crucial to a learner’s success in a digital learning space. In this paper, we review self-trust and the notion of self-efficacy used by the education researchers. We claim self-efficacy is self-trust. We then explore what self-trust and its expression means to one group of learners and use this data to provide design suggestions for digital learning spaces that improve students’ self-trust.